How to Use Blog Comments As A Link Building Strategy

Posted on May 08 2008 | By Kathleen · Comments

Software to Help You Build Links by Posting on Blogs

If you haven’t heard anything about software that helps you find blogs where you can leave a comment and get a one-way incoming link to your website, here’s some information you’ll find useful.

I looked at a software program called Comment Kahuna.  I think that software and others like it are good tools to use if, like everything else related to SEO, you make a commitment to wear a White Hat when you use it.

Things to Keep in Mind

Real Estate Blogs1.  Leaving generic comments on a blog isn’t a White Hat strategy.  If someone leaves a comment on this blog that is something like “I really love this blog.  The information is very useful.”, I will delete it and I think anyone else would do the same.  The purpose of commenting on a blog is to establish or continue a dialog on the topic of the blog post.  Generic comments aren’t helpful.

  • The commenting software allows you to store “profiles” that consist of an author name, email address, URL and comment.  The software will automatically insert the information in the profile into a blog’s comment fields. 
  • But, if you aren’t going to actually read a post and come up with a valid comment, then you’re abusing the system.  I’d suggest using the first three fields, but writing a valid original comment for each blog post.

2.  Building backlinks by posting blog comments only works if the search engines put a value on the links.  There are two places where the search engines could be instructed to ignore an outgoing link. 

First, there could be a tag in the header on a blog page that looks something like this:  rel=”nofollow”.   Second, there could be an argument added to a specific link:  rel=”external nofollow” or rel=”nofollow”.   The bottom line is that if there is any type of a nofollow tag on a page, the odds are that outgoing links will not be acknowledged by the search engines.

  • Comment software can be used to find sites that use the nofollow tag on their home page.  But, you’ll really need to evaluate each website yourself to determine whether links are set up as nofollow.  Here’s why:
    • The software can spot a nofollow on the home page of the blog.  However, most blogs don’t display comments on the home page.  So, if there are no comments, the software can’t tell if the links are set up as nofollow or not.
  • The best thing to do is to use the comment software to identify blogs on a specific topic.  Then, for each blog that is identified as being nofollow-less, you will need to:
    • Find a post that has comments.
    • Go to the page with the comments on it.
    • Look at the source code for that page (View-Source or RightClick-View Source)
    • Do a search for the characters nofollow  (Edit-Find in a notepad file)
    • If nofollow is discovered on the page, mark the blog accordingly

 What Comment Software Can Do

Commenting software can be helpful in finding blogs on related topics and automating some of the tasks required to submit comments.  But, you can’t just use the software in the hopes that all the work will be done for you.

If you’re going to use blog comments as part of your link building strategy, make sure you select the right blogs and that you put the effort into writing useful comments.  Part of the result from commenting on other blogs is that real people might visit your website, as well as the search engines. 

Thoughtful or insightful comments will go a long way toward encouraging other blog visitors to visit your site, too!

Share This Information!
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Technorati
  • StumbleUpon
  • Facebook
  • Google
  • YahooMyWeb
  • NewsVine
  • Netvouz
  • description
  • ThisNext
  • MisterWong
  • Wists
  • LinkedIn
  • TwitThis

9 Comments

1

On my real estate site, I have found the wordpress comment plugin: disqus to be a great way to build a community of commenter.

2

Brad,

Thanks for that tip. I’ll have to look into that one!

3

This is something that I saw start growing rapidly around 4-6 months ago and many people do get spammy. I always moderate comments and delete any that are just looking for a link.

I do read real estate blogs and I do comment, but I try to keep comments relevant and useful to the blog owner.

4

Sam - I’m glad to know I’m not the only one who deletes comments that seem to be looking for links. It’s not that the comments are trying to sell something, and they’re not obvious spam. But, if they can’t think of anything better than “nice blog”, I gotta believe they’re just trolling for links!

It’s especially funny when their business has nothing to do with real estate. I always wonder how they decide if this is a good real estate blog or not…

5

Hi Kathleen and the others,

As an adjuct to this specfici discussion, we’ve put out a rather lengthy Blog Comment Protocal guidance

My apologies for placing a link in my comment, but I do ask your forgiveness, as it is specifically relevant in this post.

6

Dirk,

Thanks for stopping by! I noticed from your posts at RealTalk that you’ve developed a product that helps people track blogs for commenting called Blog Comment Assistant, which looks like another alternative to something like Comment Kahuna.

No problem on the link - hope you don’t mind that I changed it to open in a new window. I agree, it is relevant to the post.

This is a do-follow blog except for links in the body of the comments.

Kahtleen

7

I was looking at a gmail tech posting yesterday from ft.com and saw the comment below (minus the caps I added to the url) and thought it seemed suspicious.

Sure enough, when I googled the url, I found the exact wording all over the place. This person took the time to manually post all over the place but didn’t bother to at least make an attempt to look real.

It reminds me of those old fake posts like “Hey, I just tried out xyz and it’s really great.” Those used to really irk me, like we can’t tell the guy posting it owns xyz.

Malcolm Waring
Pocono Real Estate

——————–

I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don’t know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog. I will keep visiting this blog very often.

Sharon
http://www.autoNOLINKJUICEFORYOUloans101.info

8

Oops, I should have read the post above mine about links in the body.

9

Malcolm,

No problem. Also, I don’t mind if people use keywords as their “name” when they post comments. You’re getting the link, I figure it might as well be doing you some good. The only thing I ask is that you would then “sign” your comment with a name. It’s tough to reply to San Francisco Real Estate :-) if I don’t know who that person is!

I know what you mean about silly comments. I usually just dump them in the spam pile.

Why a person in an unrelated industry would be “reading along” with a real estate blog is beyond me.

You’d think these folks would at least pick blogs that are either related to their industry. Well, I guess in your case, it could be someone who is interested in PA real estate. But, for this blog, it just doesn’t make sense.

Kathleen

Leave a Comment

Archives

Copyright © 2006-2009 Getting It Write, Inc.
All Rights Reserved. See Terms of Use